The Highest Branch on The Apple Tree

Posted by The Author , Thursday, June 3, 2010 9:11 PM

Quotations centered on the page are from the song "Everything is good for you" by Crowded House. The video can be found at the bottom of the post. 

 That's Him right?

"I see a man with a flag
and he leads the procession
and a woman shedding tears
for a man locked in prison
..."
Some times the strangest set of random events can lead one to open a door into enlightenment. A monologue coupled with a song elicits a spark of epiphany that culminates in an ironic “Oh my God”...

Today I happened upon “Letting go of God by Julia Sweeney.  If you are interested in watching it it can be found in seven parts on YouTube, here. If nothing else, I recommend it for it's quirky, honest and thought provoking content. I'll bow to Wikipedia's succinct synopsis;

'"Sweeney's third autobiographical monologue is titled Letting Go of God. In it, she discusses her Catholic upbringing, early religious ideology, and the life events and internal search that led her to believe that the universe can function on its own without a deity to preside over it. "

I was struck by how Julia's spiritual journey from a Catholic childhood toward eventual atheism mirrored my own, though to be honest these days I am have surrendered to the fact that I am at best described as a "Hopeful Agnostic Deist". If you need clarification on what that means just think "I hope but I don't know though I doubt it... maybe" and if that doesn't cut it, pick up a good bottle of single malt scotch and come on over some night.

"then the two locked eyes
and for a moment I was taken
and all paths lead
to a single conclusion
..."

My biggest problem with spiritualism in general and religion specifically is not so much what I believe, but the perception that my beliefs are not welcome by those around me. Though I have spent my entire thinking life searching for the barest spark of faith via educating myself on all major world's religions, aboriginal and tribal practices along side modern physics, science and cosmology, the fact remains that I come from a Catholic family who has never made a practice of discussing religion let alone spirituality. As a member of my family once told me "You are Catholic no matter what you think. " My retort of "I'm a thinker, therefore not a Catholic." was not greeted with any kind of appreciation. To be honest, I might have been a little militant and pushy in the past when it came to trying to enlighten others. The fact is that I was jealous of anyone who could look me in the eye and say that had "faith", but oh how I love to argue... Adam Clayton of the band U2 said it best;
"There are some people who say you shouldn't mix politics and music, sports and politics. Well... I think that's kinda bullshit!"
Maybe it has something to do with maturity but I find myself less and less concerned with espousing my beliefs whether they be Political, Religious or what have you. I do get pulled in by what I believe are points of contention, inaccurate reports or vague declarations of right and wrong, but as the days go by I am less and less concerned. I'm learning to let the bait swim on by without offering so much as a nibble.

"Everything is good for you
if it doesn't kill you
everything is good for you
one man's ending
is another man's beginning
everything is good for you..."

So, I had just finished watching the monologue and I was in an unusually positive mood. I felt vindicated, yet, not spiteful in any way. Someone else felt as I did, suffered the same doubts and though we reached an ultimately different conclusion, it was similar enough to lend me some solace. I made my way into the kitchen to clean up some orphaned dishes and begin preparing dinner before the family got home. I put some old favorite songs (Recurring Dream; the very best of Crowded House)  onto the kitchen iPod. As I began to unload and then reload the dishwasher, hand wash some pieces etc. the song I've been quoting throughout this post came on. As I sang the line "All paths lead to the same conclusion..." a warm feeling washed over me. It was okay to feel the way I did. I could be proud of my journey without trying to change other people's feelings (I've never really done that though I have interrogated a few believers hoping they would give up their secrets). I would not advertise my heresy, if pressed, I would merely say that I was not practicing (as I've said in the past) if pressed further I would state that my beliefs were personal. I had divested myself of the argument. I was free.

That lasted for about ten seconds. That is when the thought of my children came up. My wife and I were both raised Catholic. We have both received five of the seven sacraments save Holy Orders (six for me since I was administered Extreme Unction as an infant). I wont discuss my wife's religious proclivities but suffice to say she is far more Catholic than  I. As far as introducing our children to Catholicism, we are not regular church goers. The Wife and the girls go when Grandma is town, when we are back east visiting and we attend locally on the big holidays. Rosie has attended a bible camp and will soon be starting catechism to begin her own climb up the sacramental ladder. I've always been okay with that. There has always existed a bit of a detente in regards to religion and the kids. My feelings are known by The Wife, but we have a bit of an unspoken agreement; I don't have to put too much effort toward ensuring their dogmatic indoctrination but I don't get to sabotage it either.



"It's a nightmare talking
to a restless ocean
with a reckless calm
to state their position
but if you come undone
it might just set you free..."

One thing that Julia Sweeney remarked on a couple of times in her monologue was her regret at the loss of community, sense of extended family and of shared experience by openly leaving the church (and the ensuing, but recovered from alienation of her actual family).  Granted I never directly experienced those things myself I recognize that for many people they make up the vast majority of what keeps them in their respective churches. The human need to belong ranks right up near the top of the other evolutionary imperatives. 

"Everything is good for you
if it doesn't kill you
everything is good for you
one man's ending
is another man's beginning..."

I don't belong. I've tried. I've bleed, sweated and cried to be a part of something I will never understand. I've prayed to God to give me the barest hint. I know who I am now and I am comfortable with that. But who am I to keep from my child the sense of community that permeates the rest of her family, friends and contemporaries? Parents can often be ideologues to a fault; "My child will not (this) like I had to!" or "I will not make my child (that) like my parents did." But in the end, whatever you keep from your child often becomes what they seek out first. 

"bring back your head
here comes trouble
to turn me and be well
cover your heart
everything is good for you
if it doesn't kill you."

This is where I said "Oh My God". Funny, right? I decided The Wife needs more support in helping the kids down the right path. I may not believe what they will be learning but the fact that it is as much cultural as it is dogmatic is elementary. It took me years and years even to be able to form an educated opinion and I don't blame that all on brain washing or anything like that, hell, I never paid enough attention to my teachers to be brainwashed, I was already convinced I knew everything. The Girls will form their own opinions in their own way given the evidence presented before them. As they grow my answers may become more personally honest but regardless of semantics, I'll never lie to them.

I hope you enjoy the fact that it was through my ultimate comfort in realizing my true status of infidel that led me to support my children's religious education. 

The irony is not lost on me. I'm still trying.